10 Best Cargo Boxes & Top Carriers – Reviews & Buying Guide

Best Cargo Box & Top Carrier

The easiest way to add extra storage space to your vehicle is a cargo box. It saves you the cost of buying or driving a larger vehicle and gives you the freedom of using it only when you need it.

Cargo boxes come in different types and sizes, and they are great for road trips, ski trips, camping with the family, and lots more activities.

Still, cargo boxes are an investment and this makes it necessary that you have a good understanding of them, so you can make an informed decision and get the best value for your money.

That's why this cargo boxes and top carriers review provides you with a list of the top offers in the market and then tops it with a buying guide for your convenience.

10 Best Cargo Boxes & Top Carriers – Reviews

IMAGE

PRODUCT

​FEATURES

SportRack SR7018 Vista XL

1. SportRack SR7018 Vista XL (18 Cubic Feet Rear Opening Cargo Box)

  • UV-resistant and durable ABS construction
  • Comes with U-Bolt hardware mounting kit
  • Rear opening for easy access
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty
RoofBag EX15BK

2. RoofBag EX15BK (Flexible Fit Waterproof Cargo Bag)

  • Easy to install cargo bag
  • Works with and without racks
  • Completely waterproof and safe
Yakima SkyBox

3. Yakima SkyBox (Low Profile Carbonite Hard Cargo Box)

  • A very sturdy and durable cargo box design
  • Sleek, aerodynamic, and versatile design
  • Includes SKS locks
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty
Thule Force 624

4. Thule Force 624 (Stylish & Top-quality Hard Cargo Box)

  • Stylish and modern looking cargo box
  • Aerodynamic design for low fuel economy
  • Dual opening from both sides
Keeper 07203-1

5. Keeper 07203-1 (Heavy-duty & Waterproof Rubber Cargo Bag)

  • Heavy-duty construction using rubber and nylon
  • Fits nearly all rooftops
  • Available in 15 and 11 cubit ft options
Rightline Gear 100S50

6. Rightline Gear 100S50 (100% Waterproof Compact Cargo Bag)

  • 100% water construction
  • Attaches with or without a roof rack
  • Available in 4 sizes from 9 to 18 cu ft
Shield Jacket CG03

7. Shield Jacket CG03 (Fully Weatherproof Cargo Bag)

  • Designed for use in all seasons
  • Made with double-walled vinyl & welded seams
  • Easy to attach and use
Sailnovo Roof Bag

8. Sailnovo Roof Bag (High Capacity 20-cu ft Cargo Bag)

  • High-capacity and waterproof cargo bag
  • Works with side rails, crossbars, and bare roofs
  • The package includes a storage bag
Thule 682

9. Thule 682 (Compact Sidekick Plastic Cargo Box)

  • Space-saving design for light loads
  • Offers up to 8 cu ft of cargo space
  • Passenger-side opening for ease of use
Yakima RocketBox

10. Yakima RocketBox (12 cu ft Multi-sport Cargo Box)

  • Perfect cargo box for compact cars and hatchbacks
  • Ready to install, needs no assembly
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty

PRODUCT

1. SportRack SR7018 Vista XL

(18 Cubic Feet Rear Opening Cargo Box)

SportRack SR7018 Vista XL
  • UV-resistant and durable ABS construction
  • Comes with U-Bolt hardware mounting kit
  • Rear opening for easy access
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty

2. RoofBag EX15BK

(Flexible Fit Waterproof Cargo Bag)

RoofBag EX15BK
  • Easy to install cargo bag
  • Works with and without racks
  • Completely waterproof and safe

3. Yakima SkyBox

(Low Profile Carbonite Hard Cargo Box)

Yakima SkyBox
  • A very sturdy and durable cargo box design
  • Sleek, aerodynamic, and versatile design
  • Includes SKS locks
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty

4. Thule Force 624

(Stylish & Top-quality Hard Cargo Box)

Thule Force 624
  • Stylish and modern looking cargo box
  • Aerodynamic design for low fuel economy
  • Dual opening from both sides

5. Keeper 07203-1

(Heavy-duty & Waterproof Rubber Cargo Bag)

Keeper 07203-1
  • Heavy-duty construction using rubber and nylon
  • Fits nearly all rooftops
  • Available in 15 and 11 cubit ft options

6. Rightline Gear 100S50

(100% Waterproof Compact Cargo Bag)

Rightline Gear 100S50
  • 100% water construction
  • Attaches with or without a roof rack
  • Available in 4 sizes from 9 to 18 cu ft

7. Shield Jacket CG03

(Fully Weatherproof Cargo Bag)

Shield Jacket CG03
  • Designed for use in all seasons
  • Made with double-walled vinyl & welded seams
  • Easy to attach and use

8. Sailnovo Roof Bag

(High Capacity 20-cu ft Cargo Bag)

Sailnovo Roof Bag
  • High-capacity and waterproof cargo bag
  • Works with side rails, crossbars, and bare roofs
  • The package includes a storage bag

9. Thule 682

(Compact Sidekick Plastic Cargo Box)

Thule 682
  • Space-saving design for light loads
  • Offers up to 8 cu ft of cargo space
  • Passenger-side opening for ease of use

10. Yakima RocketBox

(12 cu ft Multi-sport Cargo Box)

Yakima RocketBox
  • Perfect cargo box for compact cars and hatchbacks
  • Ready to install, needs no assembly
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty

1. SportRack SR7018 Vista XL – 18 Cubic Feet Rear Opening Cargo Box

SportRack SR7018 Vista XL
  • Volume: 18 cubic feet
  • Dimensions: 38x19x63 inches
  • Material: ABS plastic

The SportRack Vista XL is an excellent offer for anyone looking to buy a top-rated cargo box and top carrier. It's 63 inches long and offers 18 cubic feet of storage space.

SportRack makes it using ABS plastic, which is tough and UV-resistant, guaranteeing thereby a long service life. The company also backs it with a lifetime warranty, guaranteeing its quality design and engineering thereby.

For cons, you can get cheaper cargo boxes and its 63-inch length makes it unusable for transporting items that are longer than 63 inches.

It works with SportRack and other aftermarket racks, featuring a tool-free installation that takes just minutes and rear opening for a safe access tot he box, away from traffic.

Pros:

  • Made using UV-resistant and durable ABS plastic
  • Rear opening design for easy access
  • Includes U-Bolt hardware mounting kit
  • The package comes backed by a lifetime warranty

Cons:

  • There are cheaper alternatives
  • It's not for skis or snowboards that are longer than 63 inches

2. RoofBag EX15BK – Flexible Fit Waterproof Cargo Bag

RoofBag EX15BK
  • Volume: 11 or 15 cubic ft
  • Dimensions: 48x38x18 inches
  • Material: Canvas

You may not like a hard cargo box, but prefer something that's easy to install and take off, as well as easy to store when not in use.

RoofBag presents the EX15BK, the answer for anyone who wants the best roof cargo box for occasional use. It's easy to install, it's safe on the road, and it stores easily and compact.

What it lacks, obviously, the higher level of protection that hard cargo boxes offer, although it's made from heavy-duty and waterproof canvas material.

These bags are available in standard and premium versions. With premium, you get triple-sealed bags for improved safety, plus a 2-year warranty. Standard bags come with a warranty of only 1 year.

Pros:

  • Fits all types of vehicle
  • Easy and fast installation
  • Works with or without a rack
  • Comes at a low and attractive price

Cons:

  • It's not as protective as hard plastic cases
  • You'll need an extra mat to protect your rooftop

3. Yakima SkyBox – Low Profile Carbonite Hard Cargo Box

Yakima SkyBox
  • Volume: 12 to 21 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 92x24x12 inches
  • Material: Carbonite

Yakima is one of the biggest brands when it comes to cargo boxes and that's simply because of the quality products that they make. This Skybox series takes that further with its many innovative features, such as its tough and durable cover material.

The boxes are available in different sizes, so you can get exactly what you need. They are 92 inches long and therefore, offer enough space for all kinds of long items, especially skis and snowboards.

Assembly is not required, each box is aerodynamic and offers a dual-sided opening. The package also includes all the mounting hardware that you need.

What you won't find funny here is the price. The 12 cu ft option is comparably expensive and the price only gets higher as you move to the biggest car top carrier. Quality, however, comes at a price.

Pros:

  • Long cargo box for skis and snowboards
  • Aerodynamically styled with a very strong cover material
  • Available in 12, 15, 16, 18, 20, and 21 cu ft sizes
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty from Yakima

Cons:

  • Very relatively expensive cargo box
  • The cover needs an extra effort to close properly

4. Thule Force 624 – Stylish & Top-quality Hard Cargo Box

Thule Force 624
  • Volume: 13 to 21 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 78x33x15 inches
  • Material: Aeroskin

Thule is another top brand when it comes to the best cargo boxes and top carriers, and so, this Force series comes with many features like a very stylish design that's both good-looking and aerodynamic.

Its Aeroskin cover material is diamond textured and looks really beautiful. Thule also makes the Force cargo box in many sizes, so you can choose. They include Medium with 13 cu ft, Large with 15 cu ft, X-Large with 17 cu ft, and XX-Large with 21 cu ft.

Installation is tool-free and takes less than 5 minutes and Thule includes a large lock that's easy to use, even with gloves on.

The cons here are the high prices and the 78-inch length, which is less than the Yakima Skybox length. Thule, on the brighter side, looks better, also opens on its two sides, and comes with a lifetime warranty.

Pros:

  • Stylishly designed cargo box
  • Tool-free installation takes just 5 minutes
  • Opens from both sides
  • Backed by a lifetime warranty from Thule

Cons:

  • Not as long as Yakima's Skybox
  • Thule boxes are also relatively costly

5. Keeper 07203-1 – Heavy-duty & Waterproof Rubber Cargo Bag

Keeper 07203-1
  • Volume: 11 & 15 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 44x34x17 inches
  • Material: Rubber laminated nylon

Some people also look for the best cargo boxes and top carriers for vans and other vehicles that don't need to stay permanently on the vehicle.

Cargo bags such as this one from Keeper fulfill this need but all cargo bags aren't the same. This one features a rubber laminated nylon construction, making it flexible and heavy-duty at the same time.

This enables it to fit the specific contours of most vehicles and to accommodate odd-shaped objects without a problem. You can also fold it easily and very compactly when not in use.

The bag comes with eight straps for securing it to your roof rack and this is also its downside because unlike the RoofBag offer that works with or without a roof rack, this one only works with a rack.

Pros:

  • Waterproof cargo bag made from rubber
  • Extra tough and durable design
  • Comes with easy to attach safety straps
  • Folds down compactly for easy storage

Cons:

  • It won't work without a roof rack
  • Doesn't offer the protection of a hardcover cargo box

6. Rightline Gear 100S50 – 100% Waterproof Compact Cargo Bag

Rightline Gear 100S50
  • Volume: 9, 12, 15, 18 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 12.6x11.2x5.3 (9 cu ft)
  • Material: PVC & polyester

While most of the other cargo bags in this review withstand water to certain extents, none of them actually claims total waterproofing, except this Righline Gear offer.

The bag features a material mix from polyester, PVC, and mesh. It then includes the ZipRight system which locates the zipper on the inside of the protective flap to completely wade off the water.

Another important feature is that you can use this cargo bag with or without a roof rack, and it works on all types of vehicles, including SUVs and minivans, down to compact cars.

What's missing, however, are the accessories for installing it on vehicles without a roof rack, so you'll need to additionally buy it. There are also cheaper cargo bags, but they are not 100% waterproof.

Pros:

  • 100% waterproof cargo bag design
  • Easy to install and use
  • It's available in 9, 12, 15, & 18 cu ft sizes
  • Comes backed by a 1-year warranty

Cons:

  • You can get cheaper cargo bags
  • The package includes no accessories

7. Shield Jacket CG03 – Fully Weatherproof Cargo Bag

Shield Jacket CG03
  • Volume: 15 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 43x34x17 inches
  • Material: Vinyl

The Shield Jacket CG03 is for those who need a truly heavy-duty cargo bag that works in all seasons and weather. It's built tough against rain, stones, and all the elements.

Shield Jacket makes it using double-walled vinyl and additionally uses welded seams to keep out water. Then there are 8 built-in tie straps to secure the bag in all directions.

The only issue here is that you always need a roof rack to tie it down to, so this cargo bag won't work without a roof rack. Another issue is that it's only available in this large size, so it's not ideal for use with smaller vehicles.

If you've got a large off-roader, however, and you need an affordable and temporary way to create more storage space, then this offer might work for you.

Pros:

  • Very spacious cargo bag ideal for large vehicles
  • Welded seams and double-walled vinyl construction
  • Included tie-in straps make it easy to attach
  • Completely weatherproof and ideal for all seasons

Cons:

  • It's only available in this large size
  • Only works with a roof rack

8. Sailnovo Roof Bag – High Capacity 20-cu ft Cargo Bag

Sailnovo Roof Bag
  • Volume: 15 & 20 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 51x39x17 inches
  • Material: Polyester canvas

For the best cargo box and top carrier for SUVs when it comes down to size, Sailnovo offers this high-capacity cargo bag that either offers a 15 or 20 cu ft capacity.

It's made using 600D heavy-duty polyester canvas, which is both flexible and tough enough to protect the inner contents from physical damage and water ingress.

Sailnovo includes all the straps that you need to either attach it to side rails, crossbars, or to the bare roof, passing them through the door frame. The package also includes a storage bag and Sailnovo backs it up with a 2-year warranty.

One downside here is that this bag isn't available in sizes less than 15 cu ft, but if you've got a large vehicle and need all the storage space you can get, then give it a try.

Pros:

  • The ideal high-capacity cargo bag
  • Available in 15 and cu ft versions
  • 100% waterproof material and design
  • Works with and without roof racks

Cons:

  • The material isn't as tough as hardcover cargo boxes
  • It's not available in smaller sizes less than 15 cu ft

9. Thule 682 – Compact Sidekick Plastic Cargo Box

Thule 682
  • Volume: 8 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 54x25x15.5 inches
  • Material: Plastic

While many people are only interested in the largest cargo boxes and top carriers that they can find, others just want a simple and compact system and that's what this Thule 682 offers.

It's smaller than the other cargo boxes and top carriers in this review, offering an internal volume of just 8 cu ft and a weight capacity of 75 pounds.

It measures 54 inches in length and is 15.5 inches high. Made from impact-resistant polyurethane, this box also offers some level of safety and security for your items.

One con is the 8 cu ft of capacity that it offers and the other con is its high price, which seems relatively high for only 8 cu ft. However, this is a Thule product and that's the price you pay for quality.

Pros:

  • Compact and space-saving design
  • Offers a load capacity up to 75 lbs
  • Secure and easy to use
  • Designed to fit most rack systems

Cons:

  • The price is comparably high
  • It offers only 8 cu ft of space

10. Yakima RocketBox – 12 cu ft Multi-sport Cargo Box

Yakima RocketBox
  • Volume: 12 cu ft
  • Dimensions: 58x36x16 inches
  • Material: Plastic

The Yakima RocketBox Pro is for those who need a compact and high-quality cargo box. It fits perfectly on smaller cars and hatchbacks and is available in 11, 12, and 14 cu ft sizes.

This 12 cu ft and the 14 cu ft models are 58 inches long, while the 11 cu ft model is 89 inches long. Each model features dual-sided openings and includes SKS locks for security.

Assembly is not needed and its installation and removal from a vehicle are tool-free. Although a great cargo box and top carrier, the downside here is the high price.

Pros:

  • Compact cargo box for compact cars and hatchbacks
  • Aerodynamic design reduces drag
  • The box can open from both sides
  • It comes backed by a lifetime warranty

Cons:

  • You can get cheaper 12 cu ft offers
  • It can only fit skis up to 53 inches (135 cm) long

How to Buy the Best Cargo Boxes & Top Carriers

How to Buy the Best Cargo Boxes & Top Carriers

Cargo boxes and top carriers vary widely in shape, size, and application, so if you want to get the best deal that exactly meets your needs, you'll have to know the important aspects to look out for when choosing.

Following is a list of the most important aspects of the best cargo boxes and top carriers. By understanding and considering them, you'll be in the best position to make an informed buying decision.

1. Volume

Cargo boxes come in different sizes and so, volume capacity. You'll need to consider the items that you want to transport in your cargo box and then get a product that fits the physical dimensions.

If you're transporting skis, for instance, then you need to make sure that the length fits. For items from family or friends, 6 cubic ft. will generally do for each person. So, if you've got 3 persons, then an 18 cubic ft box would be a good estimate.

2. Weight Capacity

Weight is another issue to consider when deciding on the perfect cargo box for your vehicle. There are three issues to consider here. The first is the maximum weight that your vehicle can carry. This is specific for each vehicle, so you'll have to find out first.

The second weight consideration is how much weight the cargo box that you're about to buy can handle. Each cargo box also has a weight limit, so you'll need to figure this out as well.

The third weight that you'll need to know is how much real weight you can carry. This is the weight of your load, minus the cargo box's weight, so you'll need to subtract the weight of the cargo box from your car's maximum weight rating.

3. Compatibility with Your Vehicle

Another issue to consider is the size of your vehicle, the roof space that it offers, and the type of roof rack that's already installed or that you're going to install.

These considerations help in deciding the type and size of cargo boxes that you can install. You also want to make sure that you can safely open your vehicle's rear hatch without the box getting in the way.

4. Security

This consideration depends on where you're headed and how safe you consider the area. If you concerned about security, then a hard cargo box with a good lock is probably the way to go.

In case of security not being much of a concern, you can feel free to consider other types of cargo box options, such as cargo bags or cargo baskets.

5. Aerodynamics

Cargo boxes increase a vehicle's physical dimensions and this, in turn, creates more resistance and means more drag while driving. In the end, it simply leads to higher fuel consumption.

So, if you're concerned about fuel economy, then you can consider the aerodynamics of the cargo box that you're considering to buy. It's worth noting here that premium cargo box models generally offer better aerodynamic styling.

6. Quality & Warranty

Speaking of premium models, you can also decide to go for them if you simply want the best and are not interested in saving a little money.

Two major brands here are Thule and Yakima. They both offer high-quality cargo boxes with lifetime warranties and lost-key replacement service.

7. User Friendliness

Finally, you should also consider its ease of use. Are there any extra features that make this particular cargo box easier to use? Does it come with good and simple mounting hardware or does it open from both sides?

Conclusion

We've reached the end of this cargo boxes and top carriers review and you've seen all the different and impressive offers out there in the market.

From hard cargo boxes to soft cargo bags, you've seen the extensive range of offers for all types of vehicles, including SUVs and compact hatchbacks.

It's now your turn to make a choice and this is all up to you because you're the one that knows your cargo volume and how much you're willing to spend.